01The problem
A Binder Can't Get a Software Update
Store employees at Dick's Sporting Goods determined which security tag to use — and where to place it — by flipping through a physical binder called the MES (Merchandise Exposure Standards). When corporate updated the standards, those updates traveled slowly through store managers, printed on paper, inserted into binders that may or may not have been current.
The results were predictable: incorrect tagging, product damage, theft from under-tagged items, customer frustration from over-tagged ones, and store employees spending time hunting for information instead of serving customers.
The system wasn't broken. It was never designed in the first place.
02Stakeholders
Five Groups. One Solution.
Before designing anything, I mapped the full stakeholder ecosystem — five distinct groups, each with a different relationship with the problem. Select any group to explore their pain points.
01Store managersIn-store · supervisory
Their burden
Had to monitor email for new standards, print them, physically swap binder pages — all while managing a full store. When associates couldn't find a standard, managers were pulled off the floor to explain in person.
“Time spent on binder maintenance meant less time managing the store.”
Impact on floor coverage
Every interrupt pulled managers away from the floor. Customers lost access to the person most able to help them.
02Floor & warehouse associatesIn-store · primary users
Warehouse associates
Received shipments alone and had to tag on the spot. The shared binder had 150+ pages, unclear imagery, and was often missing. They'd ask another associate who guessed, or spend 15–20 min finding the manager — then tag wrong anyway, damaging product.
“Eventually it was such a hassle they just didn't tag — or put tags wherever they saw fit.”
Floor associates
High turnover, mostly 16–19 year olds new to working. When customers needed help, floor associates were often tied up hunting for standards — unavailable to serve the floor.
03Corporate MES teamStandards owners
Their burden
Needed to push updated standards to 726 stores but had no reliable channel. They emailed managers who often ignored it or read it too late. Days — sometimes weeks — passed before a standard reached the floor.
“Corporate didn't know how broken the binder system was at the store level.”
04Corp tech & ITOperational support
Their burden
Adopted a repurposed HR flashcard app to deliver standards on the TC51 — never built for image-heavy search. The UX was poor enough that employees kept using the binder instead. They inherited a problem they didn't create.
“The binder was better than the app they were using.”
05CustomersEnd impact · downstream of every failure
Wrong tagging
Tags in wrong positions made items unwearable during try-on. At checkout, removal left permanent holes. Customers left empty-handed when their size was the last — already damaged.
Reduced floor coverage
Every minute a manager or associate spent on binder triage was a minute off the floor. Customers had less access to help when they needed it most.
“They ended up empty-handed after spending all that time looking.”
03Research
I Talked to Everyone
I conducted surveys across all four stakeholder groups — corporate employees, store managers, floor staff, and customers — in sequence. Each layer revealed a new dimension of the same problem. Corporate didn't know how broken the binder system was at the store level. Store managers didn't realize how much time employees spent searching. Employees didn't know updates had even been issued.
- 01
Workflow Analysis
Mapped the existing 4-step MES process: LP identifies candidates → presents to management → creates standards → store teammates reference app. Found critical communication gaps at every handoff.
- 02
Technology Assessment
Evaluated device compatibility, battery life, WiFi reliability, ergonomics, and multitasking feasibility across the TC52 scanner and employee phones. Identified 13 specific technical constraints that shaped design decisions.
04Journey maps
I mapped every stakeholder’s experience — before and after.
Each map traces the emotional arc from the moment a task begins to its resolution — showing exactly where the system failed people, and how Protect It changed that.
Store associate — warehouse & floor Age 16–19 · entry level · high turnover · DSG retail location
| Phase 1Shipment arrives | Phase 2Find the standard | Phase 3Understand it | Phase 4Seek help | Phase 5Tag anyway | Phase 6Damage & fallout | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Unboxing shipment alone. Products in hand, security tags ready. Clock is ticking. | Searching the back room for the shared binder. 150+ pages. Often misplaced or missing entirely. | Finds the right page — maybe. Imagery is poor. Instructions ambiguous. Not sure what to do. | Asks another associate who guesses. Waits 15–20 min for the manager who's busy on the floor. | Tags the product based on a guess — or skips tagging altogether out of frustration. | Tag placed wrong. Product damaged on removal. Under-tagged item at risk of theft. |
| What they're thinking | "I know what I need to do. Let me get this done." | "Where is this thing? Someone else must have it." | "I think this is right? The picture doesn't really show me where exactly." | "Why is this so hard? I just need a simple answer." | "I'll just do my best. No one told me this was this complicated." | "I feel like I keep doing it wrong. Maybe I'm just not good at this." |
| Pain points | Single shared binder. No copies. Frequently missing. | Poor imagery. Instructions written for experienced staff. | No reliable source of truth. Misinformation spreads. | Manager pulled from floor. Customer coverage drops. | Wrong tag placement. Holes in garments. Tags through both sides of shirts. |
| Phase 1Shipment arrives | Phase 2Scan the product | Phase 3Read the standard | Phase 4Tag correctly | Phase 5Return to floor | Phase 6Help others | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Unboxing shipment. TC51 or personal device in hand. | Scans the product barcode. Protect It returns tag type, placement diagram, and exceptions instantly. | Reads clear placement diagram with correct product imagery. Exceptions called out explicitly. | Tags product correctly the first time. No guessing. No waiting. | Back on the floor faster. Manager never pulled. Customer-facing time protected. | Knows the current standard. Able to answer a colleague's question with confidence. |
| What they're thinking | "Let me get this done." | "That's it? That was fast." | "Oh — I can see exactly where it goes." | "Done. I know that was right." | "I didn't need to ask anyone. I handled it." | "I actually know this stuff. I can help someone else." |
| Outcomes | Zero binder search time. Standard delivered at point of task. | Correct placement diagram. Exceptions surfaced automatically. | No product damage. No theft from under-tagging. | Manager stays on floor. Customer coverage maintained. | Associate becomes a peer resource. Knowledge compounds. |
Store manager In-store supervisor · back-to-back responsibilities · binder owner by default
| Phase 1Email arrives | Phase 2Print & update binder | Phase 3Back to floor | Phase 4Associate interrupt | Phase 5Explain standard | Phase 6Cycle repeats | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Reads corporate email about a new MES standard — mid-shift, between other tasks. | Finds time to print the update. Locates the binder. Removes old page, inserts new one. | Returns to managing the floor. Already behind from time spent on binder maintenance. | Associate approaches — can't find the binder or doesn't understand the standard. Manager pulled off floor. | Walks associate through standard in person. Takes 10–15 min. May repeat with multiple associates. | Next standard email arrives. Process starts again. Time lost compounds across every update cycle. |
| What they're thinking | "Another one. I have fifteen other things to do and the chances anyone uses this are slim." | "This is going to sit in the binder and no one will find it anyway. What's the point." | "I'm already behind and I haven't started on everything else today." | "Why didn't they check the binder first? It's right there." | "This is the third time today. The system is broken — but they also need to try harder." | "I'm managing a store. I can't also be the human binder." |
| Pain points | Standard updates land as email interrupts with no workflow support. | Manual binder maintenance is time-consuming with near-zero perceived ROI. | Time lost on admin pulls manager from floor responsibilities. | Associates default to manager instead of self-serving. | Same explanation repeated to multiple associates. No scalable transfer. | No end in sight. Every new standard restarts the same broken loop. |
| Phase 1Standard published | Phase 2No action needed | Phase 3Associates self-serve | Phase 4Floor stays covered | Phase 5No interruptions | Phase 6One less responsibility | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Corporate publishes updated standard directly in Protect It. No email chain. No manager action required. | Manager's inbox stays clear. No printing, no binder swap, no manual filing. Task removed entirely. | Associates scan products and get the answer instantly on their device. Manager not in the loop. | Manager stays on the floor. No tagging-related interruptions. Full attention on store operations. | Repeated questions stop. Associates build knowledge from the app — not from the manager. | Entire standard communication workflow removed from manager's responsibility list permanently. |
| What they're thinking | "I didn't have to do anything. It just updated." | "That's one less thing. I'll take it." | "They're figuring it out themselves. Good." | "I actually got through my whole shift list today." | "Nobody came to me about tagging once today." | "That whole process is just... gone. I don't miss it." |
| Outcomes | Zero manager touchpoints required per standard update. | Binder maintenance eliminated entirely. | Associates self-sufficient. Knowledge no longer bottlenecked through manager. | Full floor coverage maintained throughout shift. | Interruption pattern broken. Manager focus restored. | Compounding relief — every future standard requires zero effort. |
Corporate MES team Standards owners · non-technical · responsible for 726 store locations
| Phase 1Standard is written | Phase 2Enter into flashcard app | Phase 3Email managers | Phase 4Wait for adoption | Phase 5No confirmation | Phase 6Standard goes stale | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Finalizes a new MES standard — tag type, placement, exceptions. Ready to distribute to all locations. | Attempts to enter standard into the repurposed HR flashcard app. Works around limitations — not built for images or structured content. | Sends email to store managers with standard details. Hopes managers read it, print it, and update the binder. | No visibility into whether managers opened the email, updated the binder, or communicated to associates. | Days pass. No confirmation of adoption. No way to know if the standard reached a single store floor. | A new standard supersedes the last before the previous one was even implemented. Cycle restarts. |
| What they're thinking | "We need to get this out to all stores as fast as possible." | "This app was never built for this. Getting anything in here is a fight." | "We'll send the email and hope for the best. It's all we can do." | "Did anyone actually read this? There's no way to know." | "We've done this before. Most of it won't land. We try anyway." | "We're putting in all this effort and we have no idea if it's working." |
| Pain points | No dedicated tool for structured standard creation and distribution. | Flashcard app not built for images, search, or content hierarchy. Every entry is a workaround. | Email is the only channel. No delivery guarantee. No read receipts. | Zero visibility into manager adoption across 726 locations. | No confirmation loop. Standards enter a black box after send. | Effort invested with no measurable outcome. Motivation erodes. |
| Phase 1Standard is written | Phase 2Enter into portal | Phase 3Publish instantly | Phase 4Live in all stores | Phase 5No follow-up needed | Phase 6Work actually lands | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Finalizes a new MES standard. Opens the Protect It corporate portal — built specifically for this workflow. | Enters standard with proper image support, placement diagrams, and exception fields. Tool works with them. | Hits publish. Standard is live across all 726 store locations simultaneously. No email chain. | Associates in every store can scan a product and receive the updated standard immediately. | No follow-up emails. No binder coordination. No wondering if it reached the floor. | Their work is implemented. For the first time effort maps directly to a real outcome at store level. |
| What they're thinking | "We have a real tool for this now." | "This is what we should have had from the start." | "It's published. Every store has it right now." | "We don't have to chase anyone down. It's just done." | "We're not sending into a black box anymore." | "Our standards are actually being used. That's all we ever wanted." |
| Outcomes | Purpose-built tool eliminates flashcard app workarounds entirely. | Rich content support — images, placements, exceptions — entered once, displayed correctly. | Instant distribution to all locations. No email dependency. | Standards reach the store floor the moment they are published. | Zero coordination overhead after publish. | First time their effort has a guaranteed, visible outcome. Relief and vindication. |
Customer Excited or casual shopper · downstream of every tagging failure
| Phase 1Enter the store | Phase 2Find a product | Phase 3Try it on or seek help | Phase 4Reach checkout | Phase 5Tag removed | Phase 6Leave empty-handed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Walks in excited or casually browsing. Ready to engage and potentially buy. | Finds item in their size. But — online inventory may show stock that was stolen due to under-tagging. Wasted trip. Path D. | Path A — Tag pinned through both sides of shirt or on inside of shoe. Try-on fails. Path B — Looks for help. Every associate is in the back — chasing standards or waiting on manager. | Decides to buy anyway. Heads to checkout hopeful the placement was an anomaly. | Path C — Cashier removes tag. Wrong placement leaves permanent hole. Product damaged. Customer is last in their size. | Leaves without the product. May search for undamaged replacement — which may also be damaged. Time wasted. Trust broken. |
| What they're thinking | "I know what I want" or "Let's see what's here." | "Perfect — they have my size." | "Why is this tag here? I can't even try this on." / "Is anyone working here?" | "Maybe it'll be fine at checkout." | "There's a hole in it now. That's the only one in my size." | "I wasted my time. I'm going somewhere else." |
| Pain points | Phantom inventory — stolen item due to under-tagging. Customer made a wasted trip. | Wrong tag placement blocks try-on. Associates unavailable — pulled to back for tagging work. | Customer still engaged but already frustrated. One more failure ends the sale. | Tag damages product at point of sale. Customer must hunt for undamaged replacement — which may also be damaged. | Lost sale. Damaged inventory. Stolen merchandise. Brand trust broken. DSG absorbs all costs. |
| Phase 1Enter the store | Phase 2Find the product | Phase 3Try it on comfortably | Phase 4Get help easily | Phase 5Clean checkout | Phase 6Leave happy | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What they're doing | Walks in excited or browsing. Floor is staffed. Associates are visible and available. | Finds item in their size. Online inventory is accurate — correct tagging deters theft, shelves reflect reality. | Tag placed correctly — on seams or non-intrusive locations. Try-on is comfortable. Product functions as intended. | Needs help. Associate is on the floor — empowered with current standards, answers confidently. | Tag removed cleanly — placed correctly means no damage to fabric. Item is intact. | Leaves with the product they came for. Experience felt effortless. Likely to return. |
| What they're thinking | "Let's see what they've got." | "They have my size — exactly what I saw online." | "This fits great. Tag isn't in the way at all." | "That was quick. They actually knew what they were talking about." | "Done. No issues. That was easy." | "Good experience. I'll be back." |
| Outcomes | Staffed floor — associates freed from tagging chaos are customer-facing again. | Reliable inventory — correct tagging deters theft, online stock reflects in-store reality. | Comfortable try-on — tags placed in correct, non-intrusive locations per standard. | Knowledgeable help — associates confident and available. | Clean tag removal — no holes, no damaged product, no failed transaction. | Completed sale. Intact product. Positive brand impression. DSG revenue protected. |
Pain point Resolved by Protect It
05System architecture
How the ecosystem works — before and after
Corporate LP
No distribution tool
Had the standard. Had no way to get it to stores reliably. The only channel was email — no read receipts, no confirmation, no follow-up mechanism.
Pain points
- No visibility into adoption across 726 stores
- Standards entered a black box after send
- Motivation eroded — effort had no measurable outcome
Store manager
Middleman by default
Every standard update required manager action — read email, print it, find binder, swap the page. Added to an already full schedule with near-zero perceived ROI.
Pain points
- Binder maintenance time-consuming, easily skipped
- Pulled off floor repeatedly to answer associate questions
- "I can't also be the human binder."
Physical binder
150+ pages. One copy.
The entire store shared one physical binder. Frequently missing. Poor product photography. Instructions written for experienced staff. Out of date the moment a new standard was emailed.
Pain points
- No copies — one associate had it, no one else could
- Images unclear, instructions ambiguous
- Outdated the moment next standard arrived
Flashcard app
Wrong tool. Wrong job.
A repurposed HR training app adopted because there was nothing better. Not built for image-heavy search or product lookup. Search didn't work reliably. The binder was better — so both coexisted.
Pain points
- Search returned incorrect or no results
- No support for placement diagrams or product images
- Abandoned in favor of the binder
Store associate
No reliable source of truth
Young, new to work, high turnover. Received shipments alone and had to tag on the spot with no working tool. Guessed, asked another associate who also guessed, or spent 15–20 min finding the manager.
Pain points
- Misinformation spread associate to associate
- Manager pulled off floor repeatedly
- "I feel like I keep doing it wrong."
Outcome
Damage. Theft. Lost sales.
Wrong tag placement → holes in products at checkout. Tags through both sides of shirts. Tags inside shoes. Under-tagged items stolen. Phantom inventory. Customers left empty-handed.
No feedback loop
- Corporate never knew how bad it was at store level
- No data to inform the next standard revision
- Cycle repeated with every new standard
Corporate LP
Publish once. Done.
Writes the standard in the Protect It portal — built specifically for this workflow. Hits publish. Live in every store simultaneously. No email. No manager. No binder.
What changed
- Instant distribution — no middleman
- Analytics confirm adoption in real time
- "Our standards are actually being used."
Platform
Single source of truth
Replaces the binder, the flashcard app, and the email chain. Every standard stored with image, placement diagram, tag type, and exceptions. Always current. Available on any device.
Key capabilities
- Image-first standard cards
- Barcode scan entry point
- Highest theft risk auto-promotion
Mobile app
Scan → answer. Done.
Associate scans a product barcode on the TC51. Protect It returns the correct tag type, placement diagram, and exceptions immediately. No hunting. No guessing. No manager needed.
What changed
- Standard delivered at point of task
- One-handed design for warehouse use
- "I didn't need to ask anyone. I handled it."
Merchandise
Protected. Intact. In stock.
Tags placed correctly the first time. No holes at checkout. Try-on comfortable. Theft deterred — online inventory reflects what's actually on the shelf.
What changed
- No product damage from wrong placement
- Accurate inventory — phantom stock eliminated
- DSG revenue and brand trust protected
Analytics
Loop closed.
Theft patterns, compliance rates, and security levels flow back to corporate LP. Data from the floor informs the next standard.
What changed
- Corporate sees what's happening at store level
- Highest theft risk auto-surfaced daily
- Every standard revision is data-informed
06Design decisions
Simple by Necessity. Intentional by Design.
The TC52 device had real technical constraints: limited processing power, inconsistent WiFi, and employees who needed to simultaneously hold merchandise, a security tag, and a device. Every design decision was shaped by these realities.
- 1
Minimalist interface
Kept the app interface stripped to essentials. Fast load times, no crashes, immediate access to tagging guidance after scanning a barcode.
- 2
Product scan feature
Employees scan a product barcode and instantly receive the correct tag type, placement diagram, and any current standards — no searching, no binder.
- 3
Corporate portal
Designed a separate web-based admin tool for corporate employees to push updated standards, product images, and placement diagrams to all stores simultaneously — eliminating the manager middleman.
07Branding
From LockMES to Protect It
I developed the initial brand identity — "LockMES" — combining a lock icon, a scanner illustration, and a trust-building blue palette. After stakeholder feedback indicated a preference for a simpler, more authoritative feel, I redesigned the brand entirely.
The final identity — "Protect It" — used black as its dominant color with a key motif, projecting security and control. I ensured the name was distinctive enough to be found easily among the many apps on employee devices.
08Outcomes
A Binder That Never Goes Out of Date
The "Protect It" SaaS solution replaced the physical MES binder system entirely. Store employees could scan a product and receive accurate, current tagging guidance in seconds. Corporate could push updates to every store simultaneously. The manager bottleneck was eliminated.
↑ Tagging Efficiency
Significant reduction in time spent determining correct tags and placement. Employees no longer needed to seek manager approval before completing MES tasks.
↓ Product Damage
Lower incidence of damage from incorrect tag placement, improving product integrity and reducing shrink.
↑ Communication Speed
Corporate-to-store standards updates became instant, eliminating the slow, inconsistent manual distribution process.
High Satisfaction
Employees reported finding the system intuitive and helpful in daily tasks — a meaningful shift from the frustration of the binder system.
09What I learned
Enterprise UX Is a Systems Problem
This project taught me that enterprise UX isn't just about the interface — it's about the entire system of people, processes, and tools that the interface sits inside.
Designing the employee-facing app was only half the work. The corporate portal, the update workflow, the device constraints, the stakeholder alignment — all of it was the design. The binder wasn't a bad tool. It was a symptom of a system that had never been intentionally designed. That's what I replaced.
“The system wasn't broken. It was never designed in the first place.”